If you haven't heard, I have dumped my problematic LG-VX8500 (aka The Chocolate) and moved onto an iPhone. The recent price cut, coupled with the frustration with my possessed Chocolate auto dialing, helped make my decision easier.
So what do I think of the iPhone?
What I Like:
My main concern was that the phone, as well as the AT & T service, would provide a horrible experience. Up to this point the phone use has been a pleasant experience. Call quality is good both from a headset and the iPhone directly. I haven't had a dropped call or weak signal through my normal travel and use.
I love that my contacts and calendar is managed from my iMac. The interface to the iPhone address book makes looking for and dialing a phone number an enjoyable experience - except when you need to do it quickly (see below). Syncing is a breeze for these two applications. I love being able to make edits to a contact or calendar entry and having complete faith it will sync properly. No issues as of yet.
The Mail application is also very well done. I am able to access an account I setup specifically for the iPhone - a Yahoo! account since it does push mail - with ease. I filter / forward email to that single account to retrieve while mobile. No issue accessing over WiFi or on The Edge Network.
The iPod part of the phone is great. Listen to music and viewing videos has been a joy with this device. The memory space is just enough to fit plenty of music and videos to last a weekend trip.
What I Don't Like:
The major complaint I have is the inability to make a call quickly - e.g. one touch dialing. It takes a minimum of three touches (e.g. press, slide, touch) if you have your iPhone setup correctly to make a quick call. But I rarely need to make a quick call.
I'm not missing voice dialing (I didn't use it much), GPS (never had it), or a 3G Network (never used it). Larger memory than 8 GB would be nice, but it's not a deal breaker. Plus, from what I have read, 8 GB is the largest memory available for any smart phone.
Good phone, great iPod! It was worth the (lower) price of the iPhone.